McElroy Metal Service Center - Indianapolis, IN
McElroy Metal Service Center - Indianapolis, IN is a metal fabricator and building materials supplier with an explicit focus on barndominiums, evidenced by a dedicated barndominium page and multiple mentions across their website. Reviewers highlight reliable scheduling and responsive customer service in 11 reviews averaging 5 stars. Confirm the exact scope of work and service area before requesting a quote, as this profile is based on online information.
Dedicated barndo page
Site has a dedicated barndominium page with 8 mentions across 6 pages — explicitly markets to barndo buyers.
In Google reviews, customers consistently praise schedule reliability and responsive customer service across 11 reviews with a 5-star average.
These tags come from customer review language. They are evidence to ask better questions, not a guarantee that the builder offers a specific service today. Where a matching review-signal page exists, the tag links to that shortlist.
Build scope
Buyer support
Review highlights
Short excerpts from public Google reviews. They are buyer language, not verified claims about current services.
“At this Branch Chris has gone out his way time and time again to complete my metal orders on time. I manage a commercial roofing company and the entire team is great! Electa even jumped on a forklift and loaded up my…”
5/5Jun 2025Google review“McElroy Service Center 25 I wanted some very special screws to fix and old roof. I needed three very different and non-normal types of screws. A tire salesman once told me that the measure of a company/person is best…”
5/5Jun 2024Google review“I cannot begin to tell you how amazing this team is! Electa is the most kind and helpful person you could want. Every step of the process was explained to us and the delivery time was prompt. We will continue to work…”
5/5Mar 2024Google review
Use the review signals to ask sharper questions.
- What is your current realistic start date and build timeline?
- Which delays are most common on projects like mine?
- How do you communicate schedule changes?
- Do you handle site prep directly or coordinate separate crews?
- What needs to be ready before your crew starts?
- McElroy Metal Service Center - Indianapolis, IN · Indianapolis
- MP Brothers LLC
- Christman Bros Builders · Indianapolis
- Breaking The Law Construction
- Rainier Contracting LLC
- FrameLogic - Post Frame Solutions · Knightstown
- Pioneer Construction
- Sunrise Structures · Kokomo
- Set Apart Construction LLC · Kokomo
- Indiana Metal · Bainbridge
- T&M Custom Homes · Albany
- K. Graber Construction LLC · Amboy
- Pro Build Construction, LLC · Bloomington
- Indiana Pole Barns · Brazil
- Comer Buildings Blake Comer · Osgood
- Manchester Metals 48 · Sunman
- The Stable- at Donkeytown Barndominium · Pleasant Run Township
- Wabash Valley Post Frame Co · West Lafayette
- Barn Builders by LS Construction LLC · Bluffton
- Arcon Builders, Ltd. · Arcanum
- K&T Inc Stud/Pole Buildings and Seamless Gutters · Versailles
- Sunrise Structures · Rochester
- FBi Buildings, Inc. · Remington
- Sunrise Structures · Rochester
- Buckeye Builds & Roofing
Questions to answer before you call
- Does McElroy Metal Service Center - Indianapolis, IN build barndominiums?
- Yes, based on their website, McElroy Metal Service Center explicitly markets to barndominium buyers with a dedicated page and eight mentions across six pages. Their website signal shows a clear focus on barndos supported by related mentions of post frame and pole barn structures. Buyers should confirm project scope, recent barndo work, and service area before requesting a quote.
- Where is McElroy Metal Service Center - Indianapolis, IN located?
- 10504 E 59th St, Indianapolis, IN 46236.
- How do I get a quote from McElroy Metal Service Center - Indianapolis, IN?
- Call (317) 823-6895 or visit mcelroymetal.com/about/locations/indianapolis. Ask what they build themselves, what they subcontract, and whether they have recent barndo projects you can check.
- What should I ask on the first call?
- Ask for two recent local references, a finished project you can visit, their typical permit timeline in your county, whether they do shell-only or turnkey work, and which parts they subcontract. Good builders expect these questions.
Before you take the next step
This listing is not an endorsement. Ask for recent references, visit finished work if you can, and get another quote from a second builder before you sign.